Thursday, May 2, 2013

Soda Stream Vs. Coca-Cola

I have a confession.  I LOVE to drink soda!!!  LOVE, LOVE, LOVE it.  When an ad from Wal-Mart advertised The Soda Stream, I was intrigued.




My next thought was "Is this worth it?"  And by "worth it", I meant a few different things.  One, is it worth it financially?  Two, does it taste like the soda I love?  Three, is it worth the health benefits?  Four, is it worth it environmentally?  Five, is it more convenient?  

For the sake of keeping this post until 1,000,000 words, I will focus on the financial aspect of this.  


While I'm wondering if this is worth it, I decide that my students could benefit from my inner dialog.  


How many sodas do I need to consume for The Soda Stream to be "worth it" financially?


Act 1:  As I greet each student into my classroom, I am holding my favorite can of soda (Diet Coke) in my hand and take a sip every now and then.  I never do this, so the students know something is up.  I begin class by confessing my love of soda, and a few students chime in.  They are more than happy to share their opinions with me.  

Next, I hold up the ad from Wal-Mart.  Students again are alive an animated.  A few students' eyes light up and state they have have the machine and like it.  I don't have this machine so I let them speak.  I ask for their advice, should I buy this machine?  Then, they turn the table on me?  They want to know some things about my soda-drinking habits.
How much soda do you drink?
How much do you pay for soda?
Where do you buy your soda?
It's like they're reading my mind.....

Act 2:  I hand out this paper to all of my students.  






Little Joey:  "Did you really walking around Wal-Mart taking pictures?"
Me:  "Of course!"
Little Joey:  "Well, you probably weren't the strangest person there."


I ask students what they think.  As a class we decide that if I can get my money's worth in a few months, then I should buy The Soda Stream.  If it takes, say 7 years to get my money's worth, then I should forget about it.

I give the students all the time they need to figure this out.  I let them make guesses, and educated guesses.  They write their answers on the board.


Act 3:  Here is a link to my PowerPoint.


After we finished all three acts, I showed the students this commercial and we discussed what else should be taken into consideration when buying The Soda Stream besides financial as mentioned above.


My decision:  I will not be purchasing the soda stream.
Reason Number 1:  I have a very tiny kitchen and if I bring one more appliance into it, it just might explode.
Reason Number 2:  Convenience is a huge deal to me.  I don't feel that opening a can is that burdensome.  I don't go to the grocery store specifically for soda, therefore I'm not making a special trip just to purchase it.  It's not that heavy to carry in (especially for me, since my husband is such a gentleman to carry it in for me).  However, making the soda in The Soda Stream might be a burden to me (lazy, I know).

3 comments:

  1. I've wondered about this! I don't drink soda but curious to know about taste difference. Nice lesson! Thank you.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Another variable is the cost of the CO2 canister. The canister makes roughly 60L, it cost $15 to exchange it.

    ReplyDelete